Could Rinoa be Squall's Big Sister ?!?!?!?!

[Fan.]

Hi everybody! I'm new here

1st of all is when i n some of my friends is translating a Wiki about Final Fantasy into Vietnamese 'cause we come from Vn lol ( You can check it here if you want [Hidden link. Register to see links.] all is Vietnamese but nice BBcode )

n this morning we suddenly found out that Rinoa could be Squall's big sister
n i will show you that!
1. Julia is Rinoa's Mother / Laguna is Squall's Father
2. They has been love for each other be4
3. a quote from a Wiki ([Hidden link. Register to see links.])

Although what, exactly, Julia and Laguna spent the rest of the night doing has been the subject of much speculation, it is generally assumed that it involved little more than talking.

=> Could Rinoa be Laguna's daughter too?
4. When Rnoa know that could she crazy enough to turn into Ultimecia n turn back to the past to kill Squall? ( Rinoa + Squall ( Bro + SIs) => Incest => Kill lol)



Main 2pic: [Hidden link. Register to see links.]
An 2pc too discusion n a place too PR 4 my Final Fantasy Club! at VnSharing.net

Sorry! mine English is very bad. Hope u can understand what i'm trying to say so far

[topopoz]

LOL, Full Stop. HAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHHAHA!!! !!!!!!!!!!!

Yeah I thought about it too for some time.

[Fan.]

Then What do u think 'bout my idea? ;

[topopoz]

Not possible, but since I take FFVIII as a parody rather than a serious story, I would accept it.

NO RINOA ISN'T ULTIMECIA.

Still LOL. xD

[Darth Revan]

Christ... here we go again with another 'Rinoa theory'. They never get old... Ok, I'll tear this 'theory' apart by the four steps you stated.

1. Julia is Rinoa's Mother / Laguna is Squall's Father

WRONG. Rinoa's father is General Caraway and it is generally accepted that Raine Loire is Squall's mother. It has also been confirmed in the Ultimania that Raine Loire (Who's maiden name could quite possibly be Leonhart) IS Squall's Mother. So already, your 'theory' is blown out of the water.

2. They has been love for each other be4

What are you talking about here? 'They have been love for each other be4'? Provide extra information... however this point is garbage.

3. a quote from a Wiki ([Hidden link. Register to see links.])
Although what, exactly, Julia and Laguna spent the rest of the night doing has been the subject of much speculation, it is generally assumed that it involved little more than talking.

What on earth are you trying to prove with that? Laguna and Julia spent the night talking... OH NOES, THEY OBVIOUSLY DID IT!!! Goes in the face of what SE states eh? That General Caraway is the husband of the late Julia Heartilly and the father of the game's heroine, Rinoa Heartilly. In short, this point is WRONG!!!

=> Could Rinoa be Laguna's daughter too?
4. When Rnoa know that could she crazy enough to turn into Ultimecia n turn back to the past to kill Squall? ( Rinoa + Squall ( Bro + SIs) => Incest => Kill lol)

Oh for crying outloud!!! RINOA IS NOT Ultimecia!!! My post [Hidden link. Register to see links.] has related information as to WHY THIS IS WRONG (of course it's just my interpretation of the information available however it's more credible than just saying Rinoa is not Ultimecia and I'm not gonna back that up with info.)!!!

Good luck with your wiki, but please... this 'theory' is WRONG!!

[arthurgolden]

[Hidden link. Register to see links.]

[Tanis]

No, Ultimecia is Squall/Rinoa's daughter.

:P

[topopoz]

No, Ultimecia is Squall/Rinoa's daughter.

:P

Wait what!?

VIII is blooming more theories.

Explain this to me, unless it is of course, Sarcasm...

[IDX]

There has already been an official statement stating that Rinoa and Ultimecia have no relations. And nothing ever happened outside of talking with Laguna and Julia. Either he talks himself silly or he drinks too much and falls asleep. But the same thing happens: Kiros or Ward knock on the door saying they have to leave. I have no idea where you got the idea that they could've had sex at some point because not only was that the first time they actually "talked", but it was the last time they saw each other.

[severian]

Quistis is Ultimecia, Rinoa and Squall are half-Sister and Half-Brother... I just wonder what Ellone and Laguna will get for Kids

[Darth Revan]

Quistis is Ultimecia, Rinoa and Squall are half-Sister and Half-Brother... I just wonder what Ellone and Laguna will get for Kids

....... Where the Hell did you pull that 'theory' from? Sorceresses have the same life span as normal humans, and it's stated that Ultimecia resides FAR FAR IN THE FUTURE. There's no way Quistis could be Ultimecia. "Rinoa and Squall are half-Sister and Half-Brother"? That's a load of crock right there. Rinoa is the only child of General Caraway and Julia Heartilly, while Squall is the only child of Laguna Loire and Raine Leonhart. Ellone was a damn child when Laguna first met her!

Sorry severian, but your 'theory' is a load of garbage. The truth is out there, and has been endorsed by SE THE GAME'S DAMN CREATORS FOR CRYING OUTLOUD!!!

[severian]

creators that have left squaresoft did not endorse it, besides the bone structure of rinoa is different from that of ultimecia

and we can argue about this like forever since the makers of the story will never work with FF8 again lol

[Darth Revan]

You are utterly clueless. Thinking your theory is the only one correct, when it has already been proven (and has been accepted for over a decade) that it is false. Rinoa and Squall are not related, so stop spouting bullshit.

[severian]

Laguna is the father of both, Raine is the mother of Squall and Julia is the mother of Rinoa (in the game, at least)
...and no, I am far from clueless lol

[Darth Revan]

You're right... you're not clueless... you're a nutcase. General Caraway IS Rinoa's father, NOT Laguna.

[severian]

not BIOLOGICAL father, re-play the damn game fanboy

[Darth Revan]

not BIOLOGICAL father, re-play the damn game fanboy

Caraway IS Rinoa's biological father you plebein. Rinoa Heartilly is the daughter of Galbadia's military commander Fury Caraway and idol singer Julia Heartilly. When Rinoa was five, Julia died in a car accident. After Julia's death, Rinoa and her father grew steadily apart. By the time she was seventeen, Rinoa had moved away from home and changed her surname to her mother's maiden name.

Now, how about YOU go and replay the game and stop having your stupid delusions of grandeur.

[arthurgolden]

[Hidden link. Register to see links.]

[IDX]

The children of this generation never ceases to amaze me hahaha

[Phoen-IX]

..I took out my good ol' instruction manual just for you.

Squall

Age: 17
Height: 1,70m

Rinoa

Age: 17
Height: 1,58m

Conclusion:
No, Rinoa could not be Squall's big sister.