Tifa or Aeris' Theme... which one is the truly the best?

[Alvinz]

The thread is simple enough i hope... Which theme is truly the best... is it the lovely and cute Tifa's Theme, or the sad and emotional Aeris' Theme!!!


I personally right now like Aeris' Theme Only because it's a lot more easier to play on the piano than Tifa's Theme (yes, both are the original pieaces and feature in FFAC ^_^)... But once i master Tifa's ^____^ hehe

[nkwp]

Well you cant judge the quality of a composition on how well you can play it on the piano.

As for the question you asked, I choose Aeriths theme.

[Alvinz]

true... but if you play it on the piano... u can see all the different elements of the song, you can see how much hard wokr, how much pain has gone into every note and u can break it into different phrases and see how well it sounds and how good it was actually composed ( which turns out they are both masterpieces) ^___^

[nkwp]

Well that is a good point actually, I never really thought about it that way. I have played both on the guitar (arranged of coourse) and it never really hit me how good they were... I always thought they were OK only. But I am not much of an Uematsu fan...hahaha

[Alvinz]

YAy i finally mastered tifa's theme on the piano o.o aww now i wanna change my vote XD

[Alvinz]

*stares* u can play it on guitar? so do u just like play chords or play note by note ? ^___^ haha dont worry im not much of an uemtsa fan either... see i dont even know how to spell his name o.o

[nkwp]

HAHAHAHA!

I play it note by note along with chords. Notice I said, "Arranged". Its sort of like a melodic arrangement with a solo of the most catchy segment in the track.

[nkwp]

Edit: Sorry, double posted

[gazza]

I choose Aeriths theme.

[Alvinz]

hey did anyone realise that the second half of the tifa's piano theme is differnet ot he the second half of tifa's theme thats in the game?

[nkwp]

Of course, that is why it is called "An Arranged version"

[Alvinz]

lol arranged? haha i never actually know why my piano pieces are called... coz they're from the original the titles are all in jap =(

[zack_materia_hunter]

Hoo boy...I'm gonna vote Tifa's song, mostly because Aeris' tune is pretty much nicked from FF6, that doesn't make it bad tho...I've just heard it too much.
So yeah, I guess as it stands, i like Tifa's song better, it's more...hmmm...wholesome, has a good homely feel to it I guess

[Spinnel]

Tifa! support Tifa! Aerith's dead -_- (sorry Aerith fans..)

[jreyland]

It's Gotta Be Aeris Theme

[Aerisfreak91]

Aeris' Theme by far! Her song is sad and pretty and better than Tifa's!